Florida Grand Opera kicked off its 85th season with a resounding production of Lucia di Lammermoor, a tragic Gothic love story, written in 1835, set in the Scottish Highlands.
It’s an operatic Romeo and Juliet, only with more political scheming and blood.
On a rainy Tuesday evening in November, as downtown Miami streets flooded under another tropical downpour, patrons arrived at the Adrienne Arsht Center dressed in their finest. Bagpipes filled the lobby, setting a Scottish mood.
The cast was led by soprano Marnie Breckenridge as Lucia and tenor Arturo Chacón-Cruz as Edgardo Ravenswood, her forbidden lover. Chacón-Cruz was particularly impressive, delivering a commanding performance with a voice that filled the hall, while Breckenridge carried the emotional burden of a young woman unraveling under family obligations and romantic betrayal, and did so in one of the more demanding roles for a soprano.
What a magnificent art form opera can be.
But now, a confession.
This writer is not an opera critic.
I don’t have the musical training or technical vocabulary to evaluate bel canto technique, vocal phrasing, or whether somebody nailed a particularly difficult high note.
I’m a storyteller. A theater critic. A Jitney driver who occasionally finds himself in an opera house wondering why everybody is singing about something that happened twenty minutes ago.
President Trump could summarize the first act better than I could.
Lucia. Beautiful girl. Tremendous girl. She’s in love with Edgardo. Very handsome guy. Beautiful butt. But the brother? Enrico? Terrible brother. Very corrupt. He wants her to marry another guy. For money. For power. Very bad deal. They forge a letter, they lie to her, everybody’s lying. And Lucia? She’s very upset. Very, very upset. She’s seeing ghosts. Might be fake ghosts. Very concerning. Nobody’s happy. Total disaster. Believe me.
But seriously, what this critic can appreciate is storytelling, atmosphere, emotion, and the extraordinary spectacle of opera itself. It’s almost like Broadway on steroids.
You have a full orchestra in the pit, a large ensemble of singers, elaborate costumes, expansive sets, and an emotionally charged story unfolding through music. There’s something European about the experience, an old sophistication that feels increasingly rare in contemporary entertainment.
And Florida Grand Opera delivered beautifully.
But from a storytelling perspective, Lucia di Lammermoor presents some challenges.
Much of the drama unfolds through exposition. Characters sing about events that have already happened, conversations that took place elsewhere, or things they intend to do. The narrative is frequently told rather than shown.
However, when the action unfolds in real time, the opera becomes considerably more gripping.
The most striking example comes with the story’s central act of violence.
Lucia, manipulated by her brother into marrying Lord Arturo, ultimately murders her new husband on their wedding night. Yet the killing takes place offstage. We hear about it afterward, and Lucia appears bloodied and psychologically shattered in the opera’s celebrated Mad Scene.
Imagine The Red Wedding in Game of Thrones being told to you in a pub the next day by Tyrian Lannister.
We want to see Lucia finally snap after so much emotional manipulation.
Instead, because it’s opera and old storytelling, the climactic violence happens elsewhere, and we’re left to experience its aftermath.
FGO Lucia Pop Culture History
In 1965, a young Luciano Pavarotti made his American debut with the company, performing Edgardo opposite the legendary Joan Sutherland. Sixty-one years later, Chacón-Cruz steps into that same role as the company celebrates 85 years of bringing opera to South Florida.
That’s some serious cultural history.
As Miami evolves into a more internationally connected cultural capital, institutions like Florida Grand Opera deserve greater recognition, particularly from younger audiences who might assume opera is inaccessible, outdated, or reserved for wealthy patrons in tuxedos. It isn’t.
It’s music, theater, spectacle, history, and emotion, all rolled into one.
You don’t need to understand every technical detail to appreciate the artistry, or recognize the talent and dedication required to bring a production of this scale to life.
On a rainy November night in downtown Miami, and after 85 years, it’s encouraging to see one of Miami’s most enduring cultural institutions still making such a grand entrance.
For more info on the FGO, click here.
Support independent Miami stories.
Help keep The Jitney running. It only takes a minute. $5, $10, $25, $100, $500, Bitcoin, SpaceX stock, a suitcase full of unmarked bills. Whatever. The Jitney needs gas, and every donation helps keep independent fiction, arts coverage, and Miami culture alive.
DONATE